A couple of months ago I blogged about how excited I was for Red Dead Online. In my own defense, I had every reason to be excited. Red Dead Redemption 2 was one of the finest games I've played in recent memory. From the astounding visuals, to the complex and endearing characters, to the compelling story, to the vast and beautiful open world, Red Dead Redemption 2 was a magnificent experience.
After playing the first hours of the beta my mind raced with possibilities. The world was just as beautiful online as it was offline. It started you off with questline that saw you escaping prison and starting your journey in the wild west. As I played my imagination ran wild. I was very much looking forward to being a part of an ever expanding, open world, online experience. I was excited to make my mark and create my history in the wild west. I imagined bar fights, shootouts, owning land, raising horses, being a outlaw(or a law man), and taming the west with my friends. The potential was through the roof and I was convinced that Red Dead Online was going to be something special.
I could not have been more wrong.
Red Dead Online is a bland, hollow, empty, color by numbers experienced that seems to exist only as a vehicle for microtransactions. The world is beautiful but there is almost nothing in it. There is virtually nothing to do and there doesn't seem to be any semblance of progression or character development. Everything that kept you coming back in the single player campaign has either been stripped down or removed altogether. No land ownership. No quests(unless you count the repetitive fetch it jobs from the handful of NPCs you encounter).You can't rob banks or perform heists. You can't hunt down high profile outlaws as a lawman. You can't even do simple shit like playing poker, playing horseshoes, or taming horses(well you can tame horses but it's pointless because you cannot stable or keep the horses you tame). There's no reason whatsoever to upgrade your camp. You can form a posse but there's nothing that you'd need a posse for. There is almost nothing in Red Dead Online worth doing.
You've got a handful of options in Red Dead Online. You can hunt and fish(which *Rockstar discourages by reducing the money you make from it), you can play the handful of PVP modes(which get old so fast it's not even funny), or you can grief people. Those are literally your only options. Meanwhile, despite claiming to be a beta, *Rockstar has laced the game with microtransactions. Many of the guns, outfits, and horses must be bought with gold. Gold can be earned in game but the process is slow and almost not worth the effort. Gold can also be bought and while the prices are not necessarily egregious it's still laughable that a game so devoid of content has microtransactions in the first place.
Now I will readily admit that perhaps my expectations were too high. Maybe I was naive in believing that Red Dead Online would meet the standards of the single player offering. Maybe I shouldn't have let my imagination run wild. So I guess to that degree it's as much my fault as it is *Rockstar's. Still, it doesn't change the fact that aside from maybe Fallout 76, Red Dead Online is one of the biggest gaming disappointments in a long time. I haven't played it in weeks and barring a massive patch that adds a ton of content I can't see myself going back.
It's funny. Without trying, Red Dead Online made me feel more like Arthur Morgan than the single player campaign. Because I slowly lost all faith. Much like Dutch and the Van Der Linde gang, the reality of Red Dead Online ultimately could not live up to the illusion created by *Rockstar and it's almost as heartbreaking.
Thanks for reading.